Friday, September 02, 2005

I went to see “Constant Gardener” with my parents this evening. It’s a film about corruption – the British government is cooperating with/hiding less-than-ethical clinical testing being done by a big pharmaceutical company in Kenya. Except for some implausibilities in the premise (the idea is that the company is concealing deaths in the trials in order to get the results they want and be approved, which doesn’t make too much sense because after approval surely deaths due to the drug would be noticed and cause it to be pulled off the market), it’s a really good (and scarily accurate) depiction of a lot of different problems. The clinical trials thing, for one, and also the banditry prevalent in Kenya, as well as the all-too-familiar human theme of corruption, power, and lust for wealth. But yeah, the clinical trials thing is what really got me thinking – mostly because of one of the ethical seminar type things we listened to in SIBS last summer. Do you remember the question? Is it ethical to do clinical trials of questionable drugs in a third world country in, for example, Africa? Well, if you put it that way, no. If you wouldn’t subject yourself or your neighbors to that kind of risk, you have no right to expose someone else to them just because they’re economically disadvantaged (and I actually meant that in a non tongue-in-cheek PC way, scarily enough) and don’t have any alternative. But the question is trickier than it seems at face value… these patients wouldn’t get any treatment at all were it not for the clinical trial. If they try the drugs, well, at least they have a chance of getting better, right? Better than nothing… maybe… And then there’s the issue of why the pharmaceutical company would want to do testing in a third world country in the first place. Surely it’s not just because corporations are evil and out to get uninformed individuals and screw them over. Doing these trials somewhere other than America where there are strict regulations about when trials can be done (at what stage in development) and how the trials are done is cheaper. Which is good for the company but also potentially good for patients around the world—if testing is cheaper the drugs can be produced for less and therefore sold to less, making them more accessible to people of lower economic status (always a problem). In fact, some would even go so far as to make the argument that the drugs would eventually be marketable to the third world countries where they are being tested prematurely, positively impacting those individuals who would otherwise never have access to treatment (or, at least, a hell of a lot later). So yeah. What do you say? What do you do? On the one hand, this is a chance at some sort of help, treatment, survival and it makes the drug get developed faster and hopefully nobody fudges on the data (like in the movie). But then, on the other, this is a rich pharmaceutical company taking advantage of a lot of disadvantaged people who don’t understand the potential risks of entering into a clinical trial, people who are being given questionable drugs that haven’t been approved by first-world countries to be tested on people. What do you do? I suppose it’s really the decision of the patients themselves, but it’s the sort of situation in which they’re stuck between a rock and a hard place. In a situation like that, nothing is really a good option, and exigency doesn’t replace ethics. EVER.
I probably didn’t do the best job of stating the situation they posed to us in SIBS (an unanswered ethical dilemma, as they put it, a normative decision that has no ‘right answer’) – Krystal, wanna help? ;-) But, whether I got it right or not the idea was right. There are a lot of hard ethical decisions that people have to make, and it seems sometimes like there’s no right way out of situations like that. Honestly, I don’t know what I’d say. Probably ‘wait and do the trials wherever when it’s safer,’ but I’m not entirely sure that’s an option. I don’t know. Nothing seems right.
So yeah, I guess that’s the moral lessoning for today – sometimes nothing seems right and maybe there’s no one right way out of it. Maybe you’ve got to give up something you cherish, something like virtue (what is virtue?) or integrity or compassion in order to get something else you want, like a drug that works or help for some people at the cost of others or I don’t know what all. There are so many different things in the world to value (a blessing, I suppose, most of the time) and yet you can’t have all of them at once. And it’s not even a question of just you and what you cherish—your decisions impact the people around you. Gah. Life’s just complicated.
But yes, that’s what I was thinking about after the movie tonight. That, and the people who were there watching it. Had it been a little harsher, a little less of a thriller car-chase intrigue figuring out corruption and more of a these are the hard cold facts of the world, these upper middle class middle-aged would not at all have liked it. In all honesty, even as it was, I expected a movie like this to attract people more my age, teenage/twenty-something activist types (think Uni). Not the people I saw leaving the theater in thoughtful/shocked silence. I hope it got to them, though. I feel like that gives some hope for human nature in general, if seeing things like this that hit close to reality is jarring to them. Maybe they won’t do anything, maybe they’ll just go back to their complacent middle class lives ignoring everything outside of suburbia and their offices, but it’s something. Just a moment of awareness and discomfort. It’s important. But, of course, who am I to talk? In some other world, some other life, I’d be that activist type out there doing things making a difference etc etc. If I were braver, more courageous, outgoing, free-spirited, what have you… then I’d do something. Join the Peace Corps. Work in politics or international relations. Hell, I’m idealistic enough (though less than I was) to even believe I could do something, help somehow, make something of it. But I’m not the woman to do that as things are now. As I am now. I’m as complacent as the people I scorn if not worse, a hypocrite who yearns for action calls for action with her sarcastic biting tongue and then does nothing. The singing of my soul wants to go out there, do Project Haiti with Dan, help. Somewhere. Somehow. But that’s easily eclipsed by the moment, by my surroundings, by the ivory tower of protection that is built up around me. None of this impacts me personally enough, hits me where it hurts enough, to get me moving. So I guess that’s why they make movies like this, not just to sell tickets (oh I’m a cynic inside too) but also to jar people. Move them to action. To something. To feeling, at least, because that’s better than nothing.
That’s what I was thinking about tonight.

No comments: