Thursday, January 19, 2006

Justice Studying...

Since I don't really have anything else to do (ok, that's a lie, but I'm trying to take all of my finals seriously and do well this semester), I've been studying a little for Justice this evening. Mostly looking at what different philosophers think about the right and the good and also (related) intuitive vs inductive reasoning as ways of discerning moral principles. Kant's idea is that moral reason should be intuitive -- we should be able to determine moral principles solely through reason (kind of a 'from first principles/deductive reasoning approach') -- whereas Mill is all about inductive reasoning, which says that we need experience and a concept of the good and bad consequences of actions in order to determine moral principles.
About intuitive vs inductive reasoning, I guess I tend to think of intuitive reasoning more as deductive reasoning than anything else. You start with premises about morality that can be universalized and that treat humans as ENDS not MEANS, and you go from there. I guess I think you shouldn't need to go to outside experience to determine your morality, especially because that can sometimes give deceptive answers, but you can just reason it out from what you believe and can see as universally applicable. Utilitarianism bothers me less because of the inductive reasoning thing, though, than it does because people don't really matter -- we're just means to a utility-promoting end. Yeah, it's OUR utility that's theoretically being optimized, but the individual is easily lost. I guess part of that is that, in utilitarianism, people are entirely governed by pain and pleasure and their avoidance/pursuit whereas in Kantian ethics it is reason that governs all.
Blah. I'm really just spewing words here, and they don't even make a huge amount of sense. Maybe I'll formulate some actual ideas about things in the next few days... that would be kind of novel. Meanwhile, I'm trying to remind myself of who thought what and why, and how I feel about that.

3 comments:

Lucy said...

QUIZ:-
1. Do Kant and utilitarians/teleological philosophers necessarily disagree? What if the maxim such that I wish it becomes a universal law is 'act so as to achieve the greatest happiness for the greatest number'?

2. Isn't the anti-personal nature of utilitarianism one of its greatest strengths as well as its greatest weaknesses? (i.e. what is a moral code but a formalization of the idea that other people deserve certain treatment and that partiality to yourself and loved ones cannot always take precedence. Utilitarianism merely takes this to its logical limit)

3. 'Liberalism is logically apealing, communitarianism is emotionally appealing.' Discuss.

4. On a scale of on to ten, how much do I miss studying moral philosophy?

e said...

1. no, they don't necessarily disagree. usually they agree when it comes down to the end result, but as far as kant is concerned that's not good enough. you have to have the right reason for doing the right thing, not just the result itself. and kant's idea of testing moral principles to see if they can be universalized isn't the only determinant of whether they should be; if they CAN'T be universalized you have a problem, but if they CAN you're not necessarily guaranteed to be home free. which I guess is something I neglected to mention. my bad. see, this is why I need to study more. and I also might just be missing something crucial somewhere because I'm biased. and lazy.
mmmm when i'm more awake i'll think about 2.-4. :-)

Chris Winn said...

Applying the philosophies of Kant and Mill to the same scenario can sometimes reach the same conclusion, although for vastly different reasons. This is what makes studying Kant and Mill together so interesting to me.