Monday, January 23, 2006

More on Politics...

(then I promise to shut up and get back to studying...)
So I'm somehow on a mailing list set up by the Friends of John Kerry (incorporated) so every now and then I get emails from him about whatever the hell he thinks is important at the time. Now, I'm not a huge Kerry fan. Admittedly, I'd rather he'd been elected than Bush, but I'm not an all-out supporter. Anyway, that being said, I thought it was funny (given my Weird Encounter the other day) that this afternoon something popped up in my inbox titled 'Stand with us: No on Alito.' I opened it, of course (can anyone see an analogy both to curiosity killing the (potentially quantum) cat and Pandora's box?), and was kind of interested to see what he had to say. He brought up the usual complaints about Alito: that he won't limit executive power wielded by the President (Kerry, per usual uses this moment to make a point about Bush's invasion of privacy). Then he went on to discuss Alito's questionable/less-than-ideal record on both civil rights and privacy rights.
Does this lend legitimacy to the somewhat more crackpot LaRouchian idealists who were spouting antagonistic and urgent rhetoric in the Square the other day? Not really, if you ask me, because just because a reasonable person and an insane one argue the same point doesn't make the insane one any less crazy. That sounds awful, and I guess it is, but that's kind of the example that works. Just because two people are arguing the same point doesn't mean they agree with each other in general or even when it comes to the question of why they agree on this particular point. They will almost certainly end up on opposite sides of another debate, so they are only in agreement for a brief moment of solidarity. The enemy of my enemy is my friend, at least for a little while.
As for Alito, I probably don't agree with him about most things. Catholic or not, my position on abortion is (as Ona would put it) up in the air, so I'm not entirely sure how I feel about his position in particular. As for him upholding executive power at the expense of Congress having a say, that's less than ideal in my eyes. You can definitely make the case that having the power vested in one individual makes for more efficient actions (something that the stupid frickin' club office/receivables bullshit has demonstrated to me), but that comes at a huge cost because it makes everything depend on the discression of this one individual. And if you think their morality/decision-making ability is questionable, or just plain wrong, then you'd rather have somebody else as a check on total power. So I guess I'm not a fan of Alito as a Supreme Court judge, but I'm not as rabid as LaRouche or even Kerry on the matter.
Will I do anything about it? Have I even made a choice? an opinion? a decision? Y'all know me by now, I'm as indecisive as the day is long. In other words, very much so. And the thought of actually being poltiically active beyond voting for things I know something about, that's beyond the scope of my ability. Or at least my desire to act. That probably makes me a coward, incapable of standing up for my own beliefs and taking part in a political system that even allows me to say my piece. I guess I just haven't gotten comfortable yet with the idea of thinking outside my sheltered little life.

No comments: