Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Ultimate Question... Catching

Hey hey, it's been a while since I've written here, blah blah blah. Anyway, I had an ultimate-related question that maybe some people who still read this despite its lack of updating could answer... it's about catching.
Yeah, I know, that's one of the easiest things in the game, right? But it's kind of important, too, and I've been hearing some conflicting things. So Jefe's mantra is usually that you should go to the disc and alligator it, because that gives you an extra step or something on your defender. Puts you a little more in front, at least. In bad conditions like rain and wind (i.e. Boston weather), it can be safer to pancake things since that gives you a better margin of error in case the disc moves around unexpectedly, and it won't slip out as easily as it does from a rim grip. At least a few of the players on my club team in Ithaca, however, are all about pancaking whenever possible -- obviously, you can't pancake everything, so if it's high or low or way out of reach you alligator it, but any time it's close to your center of mass you pancake, even if your defender is right there.
So I guess it depends a little on the individual? but I'd like to hear some more thoughts and perspectives, I guess. Any ideas?

3 comments:

ultyhogwash said...

My current coach agress with the Jefe philosophy. Going to catch via alligator puts extra distance between the disc and your defender and pretty much prevents the layout D.

I still think... catch it however way you think will give you the least chance of losing possession. Now, whether that's pancaking bc it gives you more margin of error, or alligatoring bc you have a really aggressive defender... depends, I guess!

Happy belated bday by the way!!

Lucy said...

Our coach from last year maintains, and the general consensus on the team is, pancake whenever possible.

My personal take is that there's no reason why you should be more likely to get D'd from behind with a pancake given that you're not restricted to standing still. If you know where the defender is you can use your body to protect the catch and then those extra couple of inches are pretty irrelevant. This is the same logic behind why it's really hard to get D's on good players even if they're way slower than you.

I forgot to say hi- we were in Ithaca last w/e- but it seems like an awesome place to chill for a summer!

e said...

Thanks for your input :-) I was actually in NYC when you were in Ithaca, but the whole summer here has been really great.
If either of you are in Chicago any time soon.... ;-)
Good luck with the club season!