Monday, August 27, 2007

Switching Defense and Poaching

Ok, so these are two separate topics, but I really want to think about both of them and they're slightly related (both defense) soooo here they are together.

Topic #1 - Switching Defense
I think this is a lot more common with experienced teams (like a lot of things, really); it's hard to run a switching-type offense unless everybody is pretty on top of things and aware of their surroundings and good at adapting to changes. While individual switches are definitely possible in college women's ultimate, for instance, they seem to happen only rarely and they are never extended to a broader picture of how to play defense. Until this summer, none of the teams I'd played with really used switching very much, but Vitamin I definitely does.
The thing that is so useful about switching, as far as I can tell, is that it capitalizes on using current positioning to optimize future motion in defending cutters. If somebody on my team is guarding the last back, for instance, and my girl busts deep with a few yards on me, it makes sense for the last back to peel off and switch with me, giving me time to catch up to her girl while she uses the advantage of those few extra yards to more effectively play defense against the girl busting deep. Two defenders in the stack can also choose to sandwich their girls, with one defender guarding against the deep cut (from either girl) and one against the in cut. Of course, things get complicated when the cutters flood a single area or cut in such a way as to make the switching more difficult (since this is such a communications-based defense, it's not too hard to beat, unless it's thrown really well, by just making a couple hard fakes each). A switchy defense can be really weak as a result, because the defenders need to mesh very well with each other and be very used to the cues they get from each other in order to switch and save that energy while at the same time effectively guarding every cutter on the field.
I left Ithaca this summer before Vitamin I began to implement a full team switching defense (which, to be honest with you, sounds like a bit of a terrible idea in coed especially), but I definitely took away a lot of respect for the versatility of a lot of the defense to make individual switches and sandwich to improve defensive efficiency. Among the women, especially (since I didn't really do much switching with the men around me), there was a lot of effective sandwiching on the vertical stack. We did a bit of gender-blind sandwiching off the horizontal stack (so if one side of the field had two men or two women it was really easy to work the switches, and if there was one man and one woman the male defender would guard the deeper threat and the woman the in cut). It seemed to work pretty well, but I feel as though it requires a lot of practicing to perfect and it's difficult to get everyone on the team used to switching with everyone else.
Anyway, one thing about Gambit is that switching rarely if ever occurs. I think I've seen maybe two real switches in game situations, and both from the men. In coed, my best guess is that women's switches should be really super effective; since there are fewer women on the field, and having a man bust deep to guard a cut from a female cutter leads to an undesirable mismatch elsewhere (though it's really effective to take away that throw for a few seconds), so if the women are more aware of switching it might be easier to D that deep cut as well as play more efficient defense in general. Anyway, I find it a little odd that Gambit doesn't switch at all; we talked about it a little at practice this weekend, which was good, but I think we could use it more effectively to have a real team defense on the field.

Topic #2 - Poaching
Ummm pretty much if you've ever played with me you probably know that I really like poaching. Like, really really like poaching. I feel as though, particularly against a less experienced player who doesn't know how to punish poachers, there's a lot that can be gained from strategically poaching. I don't mean poaching all the time, there's definitely a time and place for it, but I think that there are a lot of good situations in which to poach.
Guarding a cutter: in women's I rarely guard cutters (reasons to not guard cutters: I'm not very fast, I'm really bad at deep defense when the disc goes up; reasons to guard handlers: I have a pretty good mark and pretty effective dump D), but in coed I often don't have much of a choice as at most one of the three women on the field will handle. Which is fine, it's good experience to play defense on cutters, and in coed in particular I feel as though the deep threat is less of a worry for me since there are enormous men on my team who can help deep for a stall count or two if I get terribly burned. Fortunately that hasn't happened much yet.
Anyway, I usually only poach cutters in the lane when they're either obviously inexperienced or obviously stationary. If my girl is flat-footed, then I see no reason not to be in the lane making things difficult as long as I position myself so as to be able to get right to her if she does eventually go somewhere. Especially for a cutter near the head of the stack, a poacher who positions a little bit into the lane and a little deep of them doesn't have too much to worry about.
I think I poach more on cutters near the head of the stack, anyway, because they're in less of a position to capitalize on it. Since most offenses run with cuts from the back of the stack, somebody near the front is less likely to be making that cut right away. And, as I've mentioned before, the thing I worry most about with defense is the deep cut, so I'm less likely to want to poach and give somebody a straight deep shot without them having to worry about the stack in the way etc etc. While the inside-out to the head of the stack is obviously a threat to poachers (and most of the reason I rarely poach on the head of the stack when a handler has the disc), getting that throw (or the baby-break) off to anybody else in the stack is nearly impossible. Soooo I like to poach, make the cutters' job a little more difficult.
Guarding handlers: One of my favorite things to do is poach into the lane off a handler positioned for the dump on the force side. It's not too hard to position yourself so that you're in the way of the thrower (making them have a much more narrow margin of error on any throw into the lane), but at the same time in the way of almost any direct pass to the dump except a huge loopy forehand or backhand to the force side, which is very D-able and even if it gets off doesn't give them any yards and lands them closer to the sideline. If the handler is stationary, in particular, this poach can be really effective, or if they don't recognize the poach and call for the disc right away.
One quick way that this can be punished easily, though, is for the handler who is being poached to call for the disc right away, then either throw the inside-out to the head of the stack (because of where the poachy D is positioned, this is often left open), throw a break to the thrower who makes an easy dump cut and can probably get off the swing, or the up the line dump to the person who just threw. In any of those situations, if the handlers are active enough they can really easily make the best of the poaching situation and punish the poacher.
To be honest with you, though, dumps that set up parallel to the thrower on the force side rarely deal well with being poached, particularly if there are two dumps back and the far dump is being poached into the lane. It's kind of an awkward situation to be in, because you not only lose any legitimate cut upfield but also can't do too much unless both the dump and the thrower are on the same page and dump it right away.

So that's what I think about poaching (mostly). I do consider it to be a really effective way of playing defense on an individual basis, but I have absolutely no idea what it would look like if more than a few people on the field were doing it at a time. Probably somewhat disastrous. I think that I tend to poach too much, which can be dangerous if I'm playing D on somebody who can absolutely burn me deep (for instance) or once the disc gets swung and I'm that additional yardage behind my girl on a swing or continue cut on the break side. Poaching is something that relies extra hard on the mark not getting broken (again, because you're basically screwed if the disc is thrown to that side of your player), which can also be problematic. There is absolutely no justification for poaching if you know that the mark isn't very strong or that the thrower can put it anywhere they want to, so you need to be aware of everything that's going on around you on the field. Additionally, as with all defensive positioning, it's really important to be aware of where the disc is on the field. It sounds kind of silly to say, since obviously you need to know where the disc is, but you really do need to be aware both of horizontal position on the field relative to the sidelines and the stack and also proximity to the endzone (I reallllly rarely poach near the endzone).
So I find poaching to be very useful, and at least a few of my teammates do it a fair bit (this one enormous guy who's very fast poaches in on open or nearly-open cutters before quickly returning to his cutter), but we've never really talked about it as a team and I'm not sure if I'm supposed to be poaching a lot of the time. I mean, like I said, it's been really effective so far and hasn't been a problem in any situation, but there's always the possibility and it's a definite risk to take. I talked to Mike about it a little, and he said that I could tone it down if I was worried about poaching too much (again, ineffective poaching can pretty much ruin a defense, especially if you think about the break side of the field), but that it hadn't been a problem so don't worry about it. So I guess I'll take that as a green-ish light to keep doing it when it seems like a good idea? Sounds good, I guess.
But yeah, that's it. Just some thoughts I was having about defense.

No comments: